Lady Spriggan
Well-Known Member
My first thread apart from my introduction thread. The basic premise behind this thread is this: complain about things that have always bothered you about the fandom you belong to(plot holes, characterization etc.) I didn't know how to word it in the title.
So, I'll start.
1) I love George R.R. Martin to death but I don't like how his deal with magic genetics. Generation after generation of families shouldn't all have the same colour of hair and eyes. Like I understand he was trying to make a point but like genetics is way more complicated then that.
2)
So, I'll start.
1) I love George R.R. Martin to death but I don't like how his deal with magic genetics. Generation after generation of families shouldn't all have the same colour of hair and eyes. Like I understand he was trying to make a point but like genetics is way more complicated then that.
2)
Also, another Song of Ice and Fire one. What even is math in Westeros??? I'm referring to Jon Snow's parentage by the way(yes I do know who his parents are)....book verse not show verse. Like I find it suspicious that literally NO ONE decided to question Ned's story to Jon being his son. Like Brandon gets murdered by Aerys right and then Ned goes in his place to marry Catelyn. According to Catelyn he stays a fortnight with her(which is two weeks by the way) and then is gone for like a year? Robb is conceived during this time. Robb and Jon are supposed to be the same age. Which means Jon would already have have to been conceived or conceived at least within the next 3 months. And during those 3 months Ned was apparently leading a lot of battles for Robert because Robert seems to have gotten injured a lot. How does it make sense that Jon is his then? Like I know the Ned/Ashara rumours....but wasn't Ned in Dorne near the very end of the war? Which doesn't work out timeline wise. I find it just too strange in terms of plot that no one ever asked Ned if Jon could possibly be Lyanna's. You know the one who was kidnapped by the prince for the entire war and could have possibly have conceived a child by him. Okay, that turned more into a rant. Rant over now.