Alllllright! Polls are in! (I don't actually know how to close it though.)
The current leaders for each role are
Captain: Victor! 50%
Quartermaster: Luci. God help us. 50%
First Mate: Niamh! 30%
Boatswain: Diego at 40% with Jimmy as the other, with 20%
Cabin Boy: Jimmy at 60%! Be honest, we all saw this coming.
Carpenter: Carlos at 40%
Gunner: Diego. 50%. Hoo-boy.
Pilot: Vivien with 40% and overwhelming peer pressure!
Powder Monkeys: Everyone during combat except Diego, Victor and Vivien. 90%
Striker: Kenn at 40%!